We had a chocolate tasting party last night and I thought I'd publish the group results for the benefit of posterity. For the record, my favorite was the 3rd place. Pretty much all of these were purchased at Whole Foods. Also, I thought it was interesting that the higher priced chocolates generally had more complex flavors, but the cheaper chocolates tended to be the favorite.
1st place: 365 Organic Swiss Dark Chocolate, 52% cacao. Descriptors: Nutmeg, pie, coconut
2nd place: Divine 70% Dark Chocolate. Descriptors: Blue cheese, asiago, savory spices, butter.
3rd place: E. Guittard Ambanja Bittersweet 65% cacao. D: Blueberries, hint of cedar. :-)
The other chocolates, in approximately the order we tried them in:
TCHO "Nutty" 65% cacao
TCHO "Citrus" 67% cacao
Ghirardelli Intense Dark Twilight Delight 72%. Smokey. Boring.
Madecasse 75% cocoa. Citrus start with a hamburger/sushi/nori mid-palate and a chalky finish.
Michel Cluizel Noir de Cacao 60%. Extremely smooth, milky, sweet, boring.
Hershey's Special Dark 45%. No comment.
E. Guittard Nocturne 91%. Strong anise start, very bitter finish.
Trader Joe's The Dark Chocolate Lover's Chocolate Bar, 85% Cacao. Cherry start with a strong finish of cleaning supplies.
Scharffen Berger 70% Bittersweet: Smokey with a bandaid finish. (Chris and I talked about it later and we both think this bar was very off from what we remember about SB chocolate.)
Endangered Species Extreme Dark Chocolate 88%. Extremely chalky and dry.
---- Post official tasting tastings:
Dagoba Dark Chocolate 59%: Very creamy with a strong mushroom mid-palate
Endangered Species Supreme Dark Chocolate 72%: Strong flavor of cookies
NewTree Pleasure 73% Cacao: Hilariously strong and long lasting flavor of alfalfa/hay/grass/barnyard
TCHO Fruity.